Optimal structures, as well as vertical and adiabatic desolvation energies for sodium, fluoride, and chloride in clusters with one to three water or methanol molecules are determined using converged ab initio methods (MP2/aug-cc-pvtz for geometries and CCSD(T) in the complete basis set limit for energetics). The results, which are in good agreement with previous calculations and experiments (whenever available), show that in small clusters interactions of ions with methanol are stronger than those with water. Only upon adding more solvent molecules the situation starts to reverse, approaching thus the bulk limit where water is a better solvent for alkali cations and halide anions than methanol.